Report A Claim or Pay Online Use the links to our carrier's online tools below to make a payment or report a claim. If you need help, don't hesitate to contact us. American Modern (800) 543-2644 Report a Claim Pay Online AmTrust Financial (877) 528-7878 Report a Claim Pay Online Attune Insurance (888) 530-4650 Report a Claim Pay Online Harleysville (877) 669‑6877 Report a Claim Pay Online Jewelers Mutual Insurance (888) 884-2424 Report a Claim Pay Online Kingstone Insurance (800) 364-7045 Report a Claim Pay Online Liberty Mutual Insurance (800) 290-8711 Report a Claim Pay Online Nationwide Insurance (877) 669-6877 Report a Claim Pay Online NYSIF New State Insurance Fund (888) 875-5790 Report a Claim Pay Online Progressive 866-407-4844 Report a Claim Pay Online The Hartford (860) 547-5000 Report a Claim Pay Online Travelers Insurance (800) 332-3226 Report a Claim Pay Online